1980, East Berlin. “Barbara” a brilliant doctor is shunted to the “provinces’ because she applied for an exit visa; masterfully developed and directed, initially her reasons unknown; she is under constant surveillance, subjected to haphazard and degrading searches by the Communist German Democratic Republic, “Stasi”; Nina Hoss, as Barbara, is poetic, hypnotic; her pain, palatable, her dedication to medicine supersedes her personal angst. Writer-director Christian Petzold gifts audiences a character that is unlikely to fade from memory.
Barbara’s supervisor (and Stasi informant) “Andre” (a succinctly charming Ronald Zehrfeld) is a complex man/doctor, devoted to his craft but Barbara’s aloofness and beauty render him increasingly defenseless and conflicted. Their developing yin/ yang relationship delivers taut tension to the provocative scenario; Andre recognizes Barbara’s unspoken desire to play the piano and he sends a tuner to render significance to the disabled, isolated symbol of refinement; the tenderness of the gesture unnerves her.
When “Stella” (empathetic performance by Jasna Fritzi Bauer) an abused inmate from a work camp, demands ministrations solely from Barbara, who nurses her with antibiotics and literature; she reads “Huckleberry Finn”, Mark Twain’s iconic tale of a young renegade, whose feisty spirit resembles Stella’s. Both actors shimmer in these vulnerable, delicate scenes.
“Barbara” challenges one’s logic; it is modern times in West Berlin, but bleak and archaic in the East; where intelligence is suspect, individuality stifled, trust anathema; but fissures are prevalent and Barbara and Andre, without fully acquiescing to their totalitarian society, show signs of subtle, unshackled, formidable resistance; herein lies the proficiency, eminence, genius of the film.
FOUR STARS!!!!
For Now…………Peneflix
SOOOOO agree with you…excellent movie!
WOULD HAVE LOVED TO HAVE SEEN IT TOGETHER!
Glad you felt as I did on this one, Penelope; it is the one that I had asked you about a couple of weeks ago and guess it just opened in Chgo. It has been at an “indie” house here in FL for several weeks and has been a movie that word of mouth has been important in getting people over to see it. I am VERY loud on it!
YES, YOU DID ALERT ME; IT WAS SO POPULAR AT THE PALM SPRINGS FILM FESTIVAL AND I CAN SEE WHY! THANK YOU FOR COMMENTING1 XO P
If you had come to visit me in South Beach……would have seen it together. You would love the Miami Beach Art Theatre!
There is always next year! P.
ABSOLUTELY RIGHT ON! THANKS, P.